Common Legal Mistakes With Criminal Nondisclosures

There are a handful legal mistakes made by lawyers when advising clients about their right to a nondisclosure. If you are reading this article, you probably know what acommon-legal-mistakes-with-criminal-nondisclosures nondisclosure is, if not by its name, then by concept. It is a way to clear a record awarded to many of those who receive and complete deferred adjudication. Thanks to less-than-straightforward legislation, the right to a nondisclosure is not always simple. On occasion, we hear stories of someone who unwittingly relied upon incorrect advice and believe they are on the path to a clean record only to find out after months or years of hard work they are not truly eligible for a nondisclosure.

Here are a handful of things lawyers should be doing to make sure their clients can avoid this situation.

Don’t Plead Guilty to Cases on Separate Days

 The law provides that a person may receive a nondisclosure so long as “during the period after the court pronounced the sentence . . . and during any applicable waiting period . . . the person is not convicted or placed on deferred adjudication . . .” This is clearly a “you didn’t learn your lesson” finger-shake written into the law. However, in practice, it ends up punishing those who have 2 or more cases pending in different courts at the same time. A common scenario can illustrate how this works.

Joe has a felony controlled substance charge and a misdemeanor marijuana charge. Both the misdemeanor and a felony prosecutor agree Joe should get a second chance and both agree to deferred adjudication. The felony court sets Joe’s felony plea on a Monday and the misdemeanor court sets Joe’s misdemeanor plea on Friday. On Monday, Joe is sentenced to deferred adjudication in his felony, on Friday (while on probation for his felony) Joe is placed on deferred adjudication in his misdemeanor. Joe can no longer nondisclosed the felony case thanks to the Friday misdemeanor plea.

This doesn’t make a whole lot of sense, but it is the law. As silly as it may be, it can be avoided by simple scheduling requests which most courts will accommodate.

Understand the Effect of Family Violence

A case involving family violence is not eligible for a nondisclosure. There are few lawyers practicing criminal law who don’t know this. However, there are several who don’t understand the mechanics of avoiding this harsh outcome. Family violence cases are typically filed with an allegation the victim “was then and there a member of the defendant’s family or household or was in a dating relationship with the defendant.” We refer to this as a “family violence” allegation. It is a common misconception that when a prosecutor agrees to “drop the family violence allegation” the prohibition on a nondisclosure is lifted. This is not the case in the eyes of the prosecutor—and their arguments in opposition have only gained more momentum since the changes to the Government Code in the last legislative session. According to most prosecutors, the case still involves family violence, regardless of their agreement to drop the allegation years ago during the guilty plea. This is a trap into which people too frequently fall.

Don’t Forget About Waiting Periods

Some cases involve waiting periods. In cases involving waiting periods, a person must wait a designated period of time after completing deferred adjudication before they may request a nondisclosure. Waiting periods are straightforward but often forgotten. Some misdemeanor offense trigger a two year waiting period, such as Assault and Disorderly Conduct. Any felony offense eligible for nondisclosure is subject to a five year waiting period.


There are a number of other scenarios which fall outside of the scope of this digest version of the nuanced laws dealing with criminal records. While the pitfalls are many, they are finite and knowable. Most importantly, they are important to our clients who deserve to be made aware before making one of the most important decisions in their lives.


Criminal Appeals in Texas

If there was one word to describe criminal appeals in Texas, it would be “technical.” Criminal appeals subject to strict deadlines and filing requirements, there are also 91 pages of rules dedicated to appellate procedure on top of local rules for 14 different courts of appeal. For this reason, even most criminal lawyers shy away […]

Continue reading...

Attorney Writ Bond FAQs

Attorney Writ Bond 24 Hour Number: (214) 403-6522 The purpose of this article is to provide some quick details regarding the attorney writ bond process. Those in need of this information are usually in the midst of a stressful and emotional situation. The article contains the most common questions and answers regarding an attorney writ bond. […]

Continue reading...

Presenting a Defense

“Presenting a defense,” “fighting the case,” “taking it to trial.” These are all concepts which mean roughly the same thing: the client has rejected a plea offer and wishes to proceed to trial or a hearing. On average it happens in about 6-9 percent of cases (of course this may vary depending upon the lawyer). […]

Continue reading...

2015 Collin County Criminal Justice Statistics – Misdemeanor

How do criminal justice statistics play a role in providing competent legal advice? Rule 2.01 of the Texas Rules of Professional Conduct provides “in advising or otherwise representing a client, a lawyer shall exercise independent professional judgment and render candid advice.” The notes to this rule go on to explain that a client is entitled […]

Continue reading...

Can an Officer Stop me for no Insurance — How Does he Even Know?

Can an officer stop me for no insurance? This is a question that has been given inadequate attention by our courts. Many people simply assume that an officer who believes a person to be driving without insurance must have based his conclusion upon good and reliable information. This should not be a foregone conclusion. Officers […]

Continue reading...

What is an Affidavit of Non-Prosecution

What is an affidavit of non-prosecution? As an attorney who handles domestic violence cases I am frequently asked this question. An affidavit of non-prosecution is simply a follow-up statement by an alleged victim in which he or she is given the opportunity to express to a prosecutor his or her desire in prosecuting the defendant, […]

Continue reading...

Recent Victory: When are Mud Flaps Required in Texas?

By Allen, Texas Criminal Defense Lawyer Kyle T. Therrian Office Number: (972) 562-7549 24 Hr Jail Release: (214) 403-6522   Motion to suppress illegal traffic stop granted. Plano police officer stopped individual for driving a “dually” Ford F350 without mud flaps. Successfully argued on behalf of client that State failed to satisfy their burden of […]

Continue reading...

Possession of Weapon at an Airport or Other Prohibited Place

By Allen, Texas Criminal Defense Lawyer Kyle T. Therrian Office Number: (972) 562-7549 24 Hr Jail Release: (214) 403-6522   The State Jail Felony of Possession of a Weapon at an Airport or Other Prohibited Place is inherently more difficult to prove than most offenses. Tex. Penal Code § 46.03 defines the offense as one […]

Continue reading...

Collin County Misdemeanor Statistics

By Allen, Texas Criminal Defense Lawyer Kyle T. Therrian Office Number: (972) 562-7549 24 Hr Jail Release: (214) 403-6522 Statistics are intriguing. Each year the Texas Office of Court Administration (“OCA”) publishes criminal justice statistics for counties across the state, including Collin County. This article discusses the Collin County Misdemeanor statistics for the year 2013. […]

Continue reading...